Case files at the input
The quality of the draft depends on what the lawyer gives as input. For a dispute about recovering a debt under a contract, the set is usually this:
1. The contract with all annexes, specifications and amendments.
2. Proof of performance: delivery notes, acceptance certificates, universal transfer documents, payment orders.
3. The parties’ correspondence, including any admission of the debt and replies to the demand letter.
4. The demand letter with proof that it was sent, if there already was one.
5. The client’s position: what it demands and what it is ready to accept.
The AI arranges the files in time order and finds the gaps: an acceptance certificate for one month is unsigned, a payment went through only in part, a letter admits the debt. It lists the gaps as questions for the client before it starts writing.
If the pre-trial procedure has not been followed, the AI first prepares a demand letter. Under Part 5 of Article 4 of Russia’s Commercial Procedure Code, a money dispute under a contract goes to a commercial court 30 calendar days after the demand letter was sent, unless the law or the contract sets another term or procedure. The AI looks for the contract’s own term for the claim procedure and puts into the case card the date after which the lawsuit can be filed.
In the demand letter the AI states the basis of the debt, the amount with a calculation, the term for voluntary payment and the consequences: recovery in court with a penalty and legal costs. The text follows the firm’s template, and the lawyer chooses the tone: firm for a debtor who stays silent, soft for a counterparty the client keeps working with.
Structure and requirements
The lawsuit draft follows Part 2 of Article 125 of the Commercial Procedure Code, and for a court of general jurisdiction, Article 131 of the Civil Procedure Code. The AI checks that the document has every required element:
1. The claims against the defendant, with references to laws and other regulations.
2. The circumstances the claims rest on, and the evidence for each one.
3. The value of the claim and the calculation of the amount: the principal debt, the penalty, the interest.
4. Information on following the claim procedure or another pre-trial procedure.
5. A list of attached documents.
The AI makes the calculation as a table with a formula for each period, so that the lawyer and the court can check any line. The lawyer checks the rate, the period and the base against the contract.
The AI checks the attachments against the list: every document the lawsuit refers to is on the list, and every document on the list is mentioned in the text.
For the defendant, the same process gives a statement of defense. Under Part 1 of Article 131 of the Commercial Procedure Code, the defense answers each argument of the lawsuit, so the AI breaks the lawsuit into arguments and finds an objection and evidence for each from the client’s files. How to prepare for the hearing after that is covered in the article on preparing for court.
Checking citations before filing
The main risk of an AI draft is not the style but the citations. In October 2026 the Commercial Court of the Vologda Region in Russia imposed a court fine of $350 on a plaintiff who cited four district court rulings that a neural network had invented.
Before filing, each citation passes three checks:
1. The rule: the article exists in the current version and says what the lawsuit claims.
2. The court ruling: the case number is in the court records, the court and the date match, and the quote appears word for word.
3. Relevance: the ruling has not been overturned and concerns similar circumstances.
In our process, the AI gives each citation together with the text of the source, and a citation without confirmation does not enter the draft. How the search for rulings works is described on the page about case law search, and the cases of fines are collected in the review of court fines for AI.
The lawyer’s responsibility
Under Part 1 of Article 125 of the Commercial Procedure Code, the plaintiff or its representative signs the lawsuit. The person who signed it is responsible for the content, not the program used to prepare the draft.
Courts in other countries say the same. In June 2025, in Ayinde v Haringey (5 non-existent sources) and Al-Haroun v Qatar National Bank (18 invented cases), Dame Victoria Sharp, President of the King’s Bench Division of the High Court of England, reminded lawyers that they are responsible for the accuracy of their citations.
In Mata v. Avianca, on 22 June 2023, the court fined two lawyers and their firm $5,000 for a filing that cited six non-existent decisions from ChatGPT. The court objected to unchecked citations, not to the choice of tool.
So the firm’s process separates the roles. The AI prepares the draft demand letter, lawsuit or statement of defense, and the lawyer reads it in full, checks the calculation and the citations, and only then signs and files it.
There is no need to give up AI because of these cases. A process is enough in which every citation has a source and every draft has a lawyer who read and signed it.