Russia: only a citizen can be an author
Article 1257 of the Russian Civil Code repeats the general rule of article 1228: the author of a result of intellectual activity is the citizen whose creative work produced it. Under clause 1 of article 1228, people who made no personal creative contribution are not authors, including those who gave only technical, advisory, organizational or material help.
A neural network is not a citizen, so it cannot be an author. The dispute is about something else: will a court treat as creative work the effort of a person who wrote the prompt, chose among the options and refined the result? The Civil Code gives no direct answer, so evidence of the contribution will decide.
This creates a chain that a lawyer checks in every content deal. Under clause 3 of article 1228, the exclusive right first arises with the author and passes to others by contract. If there is no human author, there is no exclusive right either, and an assignment contract loses its subject.
The same logic applies to employees. Under clause 2 of article 1295, the exclusive right to a work made for hire belongs to the employer unless the contract says otherwise, but a work made for hire assumes an employee author. If the employee only started the generation and chose and refined nothing, the employer may have nothing to receive.
From 1 March 2027, article 10 of 243-FZ adds to this. Those who give access to large foundation models must tell the user who owns the rights to results made with the model and on what terms the results can be accessed and kept.
The same article settles the question of training. Using lawfully obtained or publicly available works, including short-term storage in computer memory, solely to train sovereign and national models does not infringe copyright or related rights.
US: the Thaler case
On 18 March 2025, the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit decided Thaler v. Perlmutter: US copyright needs a human author. A work that AI created on its own is not protected.
The ruling concerns a work created by AI without human involvement. The court did not set the line for works created by a person with AI’s help in this case, and that question remains open for future disputes in the US.
For Russian companies, the conclusion matches the Civil Code: rights arise from the human contribution. If the contribution cannot be shown, the result may have no rights holder, and there will be nothing to transfer by contract.
China: the Li v. Liu case
On 27 November 2023, the Beijing Internet Court in Li v. Liu recognized protection for an image created with AI. The ground: a person made a creative contribution to the settings and the choice of the result.
The court did not ask whether the neural network was the author; it looked at what the person did. Prompts, generation parameters, the choice among options and the refinements became evidence of a creative contribution.
The three jurisdictions agree on one point: without a person there is no protection. They differ on how much contribution is enough. For contract practice, this means one thing: record the human contribution while the work happens, not afterwards in a dispute.
What to write in contracts with contractors
A template: adapt it with the firm’s own lawyer.
Under article 1296 of the Russian Civil Code, the exclusive right to a commissioned work belongs to the client unless the contract says otherwise. Under article 1295, the exclusive right to a work made for hire belongs to the employer. Both rules assume a human author, so a contract with a contractor who works with AI must take this into account.
1. The contractor discloses in which parts of the result AI systems were used, and which ones.
2. The contractor confirms the creative contribution of its employees to the result and keeps the materials that show it: prompts, interim versions, edits.
3. The exclusive right to the result passes to the client on delivery; the contractor claims no rights to unprotected parts of the result and does not stop the client from using them.
4. The contractor warrants that the use of the AI service does not breach the terms of that service and gives no third party rights to the result.
5. The contractor does not send the client’s information to AI services without the client’s written consent.
Clause 4 should be drawn up as a representation of facts under article 431.2 of the Russian Civil Code. If the representation turns out false, the contractor pays damages or the penalty set in the contract, and a client for whom the representation was material may terminate the contract.
How to record the human contribution in practice:
1. Keep the prompts and parameters used to get each option;
2. Save interim versions and employees’ edits with dates;
3. State in the acceptance report which employees selected and refined the result.
The fifth clause protects not only rights but also confidentiality: the text of a contract or case materials sent to someone else’s service is no longer under the client’s control. The other terms on data, logs and replacing the model are on the page about the contract with an AI vendor.