MMOOZZGG.com

AI for lawyers

Court fined for AI fake case law: how Russian courts punish invented references

6 min read9 sources

A Russian court first fined a party for AI fake case law in May 2026: the Arbitration Court of the West Siberian District collected $600 from a company whose lawyers cited non-existent rulings from a neural network. In October, the Arbitration Court of the Vologda Region fined a claimant $350 for four invented rulings. Below are the case numbers, the courts’ reasons, and a procedure that protects against such a fine.

On this page · 4 sections

The first fine: May 2026

The Arbitration Court of the West Siberian District heard case No. A27–7831/2025 on cassation, the third level of appeal. In the cassation appeal, the company’s lawyers cited non-existent court acts with direct quotes that a neural network had invented.

At the hearing, the defendant’s representative confirmed that no such rulings exist. The court called this a direct deception of the court, counting on a shallow reading of the appeal’s arguments, and did not accept preparing the appeal with AI as an excuse.

The court rejected the argument that the lawyers had made a mistake. The appeal was signed by an authorized representative, and the company did not withdraw it until the court itself found the false references, set a hearing, and asked for explanations.

The company’s new representative asked the court to disregard these references. The court replied that contempt of court had already taken place as a completed procedural offense and imposed a fine of $600.

According to media reports, this is the first such fine in Russia. Rossiyskaya Gazeta gave the case number and the reasons of the ruling on 18 May 2026.

The second fine: October 2026

The Arbitration Court of the Vologda Region is hearing case No. A13–14310/2025 on damages under a construction contract. Through the court’s online filing system (My Arbitr), the claimant filed a statement clarifying its claims and cited rulings of the Arbitration Court of the North-Western District in four cases.

The dispute is large: the claims grew from $690,000 to $870,000. The claimant’s director signed the statement with the references, so the document came in the company’s name.

In September, the defendant asked the court to fine the claimant. The court checked the references: there are no such rulings in the national register of arbitration cases, and the case numbers are real, but other disputes were heard under them, from a settlement agreement to a sublease debt.

The claimant said it copied the rulings from open sources on the internet, but it could not name the source. The court issued a ruling with a fine of $350 and on 5 October 2026 reported it on its website as case law generated by AI.

This is the second fine on a company for case law invented by AI. Between the two cases, Pravo.ru reported on 28 August 2026 that the Intellectual Property Court fined a sole trader $60 for 12 false references in a cassation appeal (case No. A71–11377/2025).

How the court classified it

Both courts called the filing of invented case law contempt of court. According to Pravo.ru, the Vologda fine was imposed under part 5 of article 119 of the Arbitration Procedure Code of Russia.

The amount is set by part 1 of article 119 of the Arbitration Procedure Code. According to analysts interviewed by Rossiyskaya Gazeta, the West Siberian fine of $600 was half of the $1,200 limit.

A reference to AI does not release a party from liability. The West Siberian District relied on part 2 of article 9 of the Arbitration Procedure Code: the party to the case that used the technology is responsible for the accuracy of the generated text.

The Supreme Court stated the general rule in ruling No. 301-ES21–23756. Parties may not knowingly cite non-existent rules and explanations, and a party that prepares its position with the help of software does so at its own risk and must check the result.

In that case, a creditor’s representative cited paragraph 15 of Plenum resolution No. 48 of the Supreme Court of 25 December 2018, which has 14 paragraphs. The Supreme Court sent the question of a personal fine on the representative to the court of first instance.

The argument “it was an error of the AI or the lawyer” does not work in the Intellectual Property Court either. The sole trader’s representative said the trader should not answer for the lawyer’s mistakes, but the court assessed these arguments critically and fined the trader himself.

How to avoid a fine

Such cases are growing in number: as of 15 October 2026, a global database lists 2,190 cases of content invented by AI. The procedure before you file a document with a court:

1. Open each court act by its details in the national register of arbitration cases or on the court’s website. A matching number is not enough: in the Vologda case, the numbers were real, but the disputes were different.

2. Find the quote word for word in the text of the act, with the paragraph number.

3. Check that the act has not been overturned and that the rule applies in the right version.

4. The person who checked the references signs the document, or records the check in a log.

5. Fix an error found after filing at once. In case No. A27–7831/2025, a late withdrawal of the references did not prevent the fine, so the check is needed before filing.

6. Record where AI prepared the draft. The Supreme Court’s concept already proposes declaring the use of AI when filing documents, and an internal note will make the transition easier.

Courts are getting ready to check references themselves. The Supreme Court’s Concept for the introduction of AI names the filing of materials with false references as a separate risk and proposes automatic reference checks, declaring the use of AI, and procedural sanctions.

An AI agent inside the firm’s closed network can check each reference against a database of court acts and flag the ones it cannot find. The signature and the decision to file stay with the lawyer. How AI helps in arbitration proceedings is covered separately.

Sources and fact-checking

Checked by the editors on 16 October 2026.

  1. Peterburg2, citing Rossiyskaya Gazeta, 19 May 2026 (peterburg2.ru)
  2. RAPSI, 5 October 2026 (rapsinews.ru)
  3. AI Hallucination Cases Database, 15.10.2026 (damiencharlotin.com)
  4. Rossiyskaya Gazeta, 18 May 2026 (rg.ru)
  5. Arbitration Court of the Vologda Region, 5 October 2026 (vologda.arbitr.ru)
  6. Pravo.ru, 5 October 2026 (pravo.ru)
  7. Pravo.ru, 28 August 2026 (pravo.ru)
  8. RAPSI, 9 September 2026 (rapsinews.ru)
  9. Garant, text of the order, 3 September 2026 (base.garant.ru)

Found a mistake? Tell us

Publications

Mike Mozg

Agentic AI use cases at AT&T: nearly 500 processes now run on agents

AT&T no longer uses AI only to help staff work faster: it is rebuilding whole business processes around agents. SiliconANGLE reported on 14 November 2026 that nearly 500 agentic AI use cases at AT&T are already in production. Here is how the company rebuilds them, where a human still checks the agent, and what other large companies can take from it.

News4 min
Contact us