When consent is needed
Consent rests on three separate grounds, and each answers its own question.
1. Attorney-client privilege. Under Article 8 of Russia’s Law on Advocacy, privilege covers any information connected with legal help to the client, and only the client can release the lawyer from it.
2. Processing by another party. Under part 3 of Article 6 of 152-FZ, Russia’s personal data law, an operator may entrust processing of personal data to another person with the data subject’s consent, unless a federal law provides otherwise. The vendor of an AI service that receives documents with personal data is such a person.
3. Cross-border transfer. If the service is abroad, the operator notifies Roskomnadzor, Russia’s communications regulator, before the transfer (part 3 of Article 12 of 152-FZ), and the client should be told plainly which country gets their information.
When consent is usually not needed: a lawyer asks a service a general question with no case details, or works with published texts of laws and court decisions.
If the client is a company, the second ground concerns not the company but the people in the documents: directors, employees and individual counterparties. The company’s consent to AI work settles the privilege question, but the personal data of these people needs its own ground under Article 6 of 152-FZ.
A model on the firm’s server or in a cloud in Russia removes the cross-border transfer question. The privilege question remains: tell the client about AI work in any case.
The FPA and ABA positions
In December 2025, FPA vice president Sergey Zubkov said that the law does not ban AI for lawyers and that an FPA working group is developing approaches. He warned that sending sensitive data to foreign servers can lead to its disclosure.
In Formal Opinion 512 of 29 July 2024, the American Bar Association lists a lawyer’s duties when using generative AI: competence, confidentiality of client information, informing the client and a reasonable fee.
Both positions agree on the main point: AI is allowed, but the client knows about it in advance, and the client’s information does not go where it could be disclosed. The difference is in form: the ABA speaks of informing the client and confidentiality, while the FPA names consent directly.
For Russian practice, written form is safer. An oral warning is hard to prove if the client later says they did not know their information went to an AI service.
Wording for the agreement
A sample; adapt it with the firm’s lawyer.
A clause for a legal services agreement or an agreement with an advocate:
1. The Client agrees that, in providing legal help, the Contractor uses artificial intelligence systems to prepare draft documents and to search and analyze information. Decisions on the case, checking the result and signing documents are done by the Contractor’s lawyer.
2. The Contractor processes the Client’s information with artificial intelligence systems only on servers in the Russian Federation and does not pass it to third parties, except those listed in the Annex.
3. Cross-border transfer of the Client’s information is allowed only with the Client’s separate written consent.
4. The Client may at any time ban the use of artificial intelligence systems on their case in writing; the ban takes effect from the date the Contractor receives the notice.
The Annex lists the services, their vendors, the place of processing and the purpose. If the firm changes a service, the annex is updated and the client is notified.
Consent to personal data processing is not included in this clause. Under part 1 of Article 9 of 152-FZ, as amended by 156-FZ, it is given separately from other documents the data subject signs, and it must be specific, substantive, informed, conscious and unambiguous.
So an individual’s consent to processing by the vendors in the Annex is given in a separate document. The operator must prove that it obtained consent (part 3 of Article 9), so the signed copy is kept in the case file.
What to tell the client in person
A conversation does not replace written consent, but it removes the client’s main fear. It is enough to answer the four questions the client will ask anyway:
Have the conversation before the agreement is signed, not after the first document; otherwise the consent question looks like an excuse.
1. What AI does: it prepares drafts and finds what is needed in the case documents and in case law. The decision and the signature stay with the lawyer.
2. Where the information is processed: name the country and the type of service, for example a model on the firm’s server in Russia.
3. Who checks the result: every reference to a rule or a court decision is checked against the original source.
4. How to opt out: a written ban on the case takes effect from the date it is received.
In Formal Opinion 512, the ABA links informing the client with a reasonable fee. If AI cut the hours spent on a document, tell the client how this shows in the bill.
The firm’s AI use policy sets the internal rules for working with AI that this conversation relies on. If the client asks what rules the lawyers follow, you can show its sections as they are.