What Article 8 protects
Article 8 of Russia’s Federal Law on Advocacy treats as advocate secrecy any information related to legal help for a client. Only the client can release the advocate from it.
The Code of Professional Ethics of the Advocate lists what the secret covers in Article 6(5). It covers almost everything a lawyer could paste into a chat window:
1. The fact that a client came to the advocate, including the names of clients.
2. Evidence and documents collected to prepare the case.
3. Information from the client and the content of legal advice.
4. The advocate’s file on the case and the fee terms, including calculations.
The secret has no time limit (Article 6(2) of the Code), and the client’s consent to end it is given in writing and in the advocate’s presence (Article 6(3)). If an upload to a service means passing information to a third party, it is already disclosure of the secret, and a spoken “fine” from the client is not enough.
Lawyers without advocate status do not have this rule, but the client’s commercial secret, the contract terms and the requirements of 152-FZ if the documents hold personal data still apply (152-FZ is Russia’s personal data law).
Why a public service is a third party
A public AI service runs on the provider’s servers. A request with part of a case goes to a company that has no duty to keep advocate secrecy, and it is stored by that company’s rules, not by the rules of the bar.
Providers do not hide this. On 25 July 2025 OpenAI CEO Sam Altman said that conversations with ChatGPT have no legal protection like a conversation with a lawyer or a doctor, and that the company would have to disclose them if a court required it.
What to read in the terms of a service before the first upload:
1. Where requests and answers are stored, and for how long.
2. Whether they train the model, and whether this can be switched off.
3. To whom the provider may disclose data: contractors, state bodies, a court.
4. In which country the servers are, and whether there is a data processing agreement.
If even one question has no answer, the client’s information does not go there. A question about a rule or case law without case facts, names or amounts is a different matter: it holds no secret.
A business plan with a data processing agreement may change the answers to the first two questions, but check the third and fourth separately, against the text of the agreement.
The Heppner case: chats with AI are not privileged
A US court made the first ruling on this topic. In United States v. Heppner, Judge Jed Rakoff of the Southern District of New York held in an opinion of 17 February 2026 that the defendant’s chats with a public AI service are not protected by attorney-client privilege and are not attorney work product.
The court’s main argument was the service’s policy, under which requests and answers are collected and may be disclosed to third parties. Under such terms, nobody can expect confidentiality.
US privilege and Russian advocate secrecy work differently, but the practical lesson is the same: information already held by a service provider is no longer under the advocate’s control. The facts, the court’s reasoning and criticism of the ruling are in the review of the Heppner case.
The FPA position
The Federal Chamber of Lawyers of Russia (FPA) does not ban AI. In December 2025 Sergey Zubkov, Vice President of the FPA, said the law does not forbid advocates to use AI, and a working group of the chamber is developing approaches.
The same talk named two conditions. Sending sensitive data to servers abroad may lead to its disclosure. The client must be warned and must give consent.
Until the working group issues final rules, it makes sense to treat these two conditions as the minimum for every advocate who works with AI.
The approach in the United States is similar. In Formal Opinion 512 of 29 July 2024, the American Bar Association stated that a lawyer who uses generative AI is responsible for competence, confidentiality of client information, communication with the client and a reasonable fee.
How to draft the client’s consent and where to put it in the engagement agreement is covered in the article on client consent to AI.
How to work safely
A safe setup rests on how the work is organized, not on a ban. A ban without a replacement pushes lawyers into personal accounts, where the firm no longer sees anything.
1. The model runs on the firm’s server or in a cloud in Russia, and case materials do not go abroad or to services without a data processing agreement.
2. The client knows about the use of AI and agrees to it: a clause in the agreement or a separate document, as the FPA advises.
3. Only questions without case facts, names or company details go to public services.
4. Each lawyer has access only to their own cases, and AI actions are logged.
5. A lawyer checks every citation of a law or court decision, and the position in the case and the signature stay with the lawyer.
How a closed model for a firm works and what the server costs is on the page about local AI for lawyers. The technical rules of data protection are in the block below.