Analyzing the tax audit report
A tax audit report has a predictable structure. Under Article 100, point 3 of the Russian Tax Code, it states the documented facts of violations, the list of documents the audited taxpayer submitted, and the auditors’ conclusions and proposals with references to the articles of the code. The documents that confirm the violations are attached to the report (Article 100, point 3.1).
This structure suits AI. It splits the report into episodes and builds a table for each one:
1. What is charged: the tax, the period, the amount of additional tax, the penalties and the fine.
2. Which evidence the conclusion rests on: interviews, counter-audits, statements, with a link to the page of the annex.
3. Which client documents the tax authority mentioned and which it ignored, although they are in the list of submitted documents.
4. Where a conclusion has no support in an annex or contradicts another part of the report.
The lawyer gets a map of the report before sitting down to the objections, and sees earlier which episodes to dispute and which to accept.
The report and its annexes contain tax secrets and personal data of employees and counterparties. So the analysis runs in a closed environment: we process personal data on servers in Russia under 152-FZ, the Russian personal data law, and the text does not go abroad or to services without a data processing agreement.
Case law by episode
Many disputes over deductions and expenses come down to Article 54.1 of the Russian Tax Code. The tax authority proves a distortion of information about business facts, or that the main purpose of a deal was not paying tax, or that the obligation was performed neither by the counterparty under the contract nor by a person it was transferred to under a contract or the law.
For each episode, AI looks for court decisions on the same ground: the same tax, a similar scheme, a similar set of evidence. The result is a short list of cases with extracts and links to the text of the decision, not a retelling from the model’s memory.
Checking the references is a must. According to Stanford RegLab and HAI, May 2024, legal AI case law tools make mistakes in more than 17% of answers, and general chatbots in an earlier study got 58–82% of legal questions wrong. So the system shows only decisions it found in the database and can open, and the lawyer checks the case number and the quote.
How AI case law search works and why every reference opens in its source is covered on a separate page.
Objections and appeals
Deadlines in a tax dispute are short. Written objections to the report are filed within one month of receiving it, and you may attach documents to them (Article 100, point 6 of the Russian Tax Code). The head of the tax authority reviews the materials and makes a decision within 10 days after this term ends (Article 101, point 1).
The decision takes effect one month after it is delivered (Article 101, point 9). Before that day, you file an appeal to the higher tax authority (Article 139.1, point 2), and you can challenge the decision in court only after the pre-trial appeal (Article 138, point 2).
AI prepares drafts in a structure the firm sets once:
1. Objections to the report by episode: the auditors’ conclusion, the client’s argument, the evidence, the rule.
2. A list of documents for the objections, with a note on what was already handed over during the audit.
3. An appeal based on the objections, taking into account what the tax authority answered in its decision.
4. A case calendar: the date the report was received, the last day for objections, the date the decision was delivered, the last day for the appeal.
The draft relies on the case documents and on case law the lawyer has already checked. The lawyer decides what to file and in which wording, and signs the document.
Mitigating circumstances
Article 112, point 1 of the Russian Tax Code names as mitigating: serious personal or family circumstances, threats, coercion or dependence, the difficult financial situation of an individual, and other circumstances that a court or the tax authority recognizes. The last item is open, and this is where the lawyer collects most arguments.
Since 1 September 2026, a new wording of Article 114, point 3 of the Russian Tax Code applies, introduced by Federal Law No. 425-FZ of 28 November 2025: with at least one mitigating circumstance, the fine is cut at least 2 times and at most 10 times. The tax authority takes mitigating circumstances into account with special rules that the Federal Tax Service approves. The amendment is covered in detail in the article on tax fines from 1 September 2026.
Before, the law set only the lower limit of the reduction. Now the reduction has a ceiling, and the client should hear in advance about the range within which a court or the tax inspectorate can cut the fine.
AI helps to collect the arguments before the objections, not after the decision:
1. It searches the client’s correspondence and documents for circumstances that can be claimed as mitigating.
2. It finds case law on similar circumstances, with links that the lawyer checks.
3. It drafts a section of the objections with the fine calculated for a 2-fold and a 10-fold reduction.