Two fines in 2026
The first case became known in May 2026. The Arbitration Court of the West Siberian District fined a company $600: its cassation appeal cited non-existent court rulings created by an AI tool. According to media reports, this was the first such fine in Russia.
The second case happened in October 2026. The Arbitration Court of the Vologda Region imposed a court fine of $350 on a claimant who cited four rulings of the district court. An AI tool had generated all four.
In both cases, the court punished not the software but the party that filed the document. The person who signs a claim or an appeal is responsible for its content, and the argument “that is what the AI answered” does not remove this responsibility.
The lesson for practice is not to give up AI. The mistake in both cases was the same: nobody opened the cited ruling before filing. This check takes minutes, and it can be built into the work so that it does not depend on a lawyer’s memory or fatigue.
The timeline and details of both cases are collected in the review of court fines for AI, which is updated as new rulings appear.
Searching the practice of district courts
A commercial litigator most often looks for the position of the cassation court of their district: the district court reviews whether lower court rulings are lawful, and its rulings guide the first instance and appeal courts. These were exactly the rulings the AI tool invented in the Vologda case.
The reason lies in how a general chatbot works. It does not look up a ruling in a database; it writes text that looks like an answer. A case number, a date and a quote can look plausible and still not exist.
A working setup is different: AI searches only a database of real rulings. This is an export from the register of commercial cases, the firm’s collections by practice area and the rulings the lawyer has already added to the case.
1. Query: the subject of the dispute, the legal rule, the district, the period.
2. Selection: AI finds rulings in the database and groups them by the court’s position, separately in favor of the claimant and in favor of the defendant.
3. Brief: the point, the case number, the date and a quote with its place in the text of the ruling.
4. Decision: the lawyer opens each ruling and chooses what goes into the document.
The system marks an answer without a source as unverified, and it does not go into the brief. How to set up court practice search for your firm’s cases is covered separately.
Courts are moving the same way. Order No. 59-P of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of 3 September 2026 approved the Concept for introducing AI technologies into court proceedings: recording hearings, assigning cases, preparing draft decisions. AI remains a tool of the judge, and a person makes the decision.
Procedural deadlines
In Russian commercial litigation, deadlines are short and the cost of missing one is high. Under Part 1 of Article 259 of the Arbitration Procedure Code, an appeal is filed within one month after the decision, unless the code sets another term.
For cassation, the term is different: under Part 1 of Article 276 of the Code, an appeal is filed no later than two months from the day the ruling under appeal enters into force. The count starts from a different event here, and it is easy to get it wrong.
Article 115 of the Code names the consequence of a missed deadline: the parties to the case lose the right to the procedural action. The court does not consider an appeal filed late without a motion to restore or extend the term, and returns it.
Restoring the term is no safety net. Under Part 2 of Article 259 and Part 2 of Article 276 of the Code, a term is restored only if it was missed for reasons beyond the applicant’s control and the motion was filed no later than six months.
Here AI works as a second controller. It reads every order and decision that arrives in the case, finds the date of issue or entry into force, calculates the deadline and puts it in the responsible lawyer’s calendar with an early reminder. A person confirms the final date.
The check before filing
One procedure could have prevented both 2026 fines. Fix it in the firm’s rules and apply it to every document that goes to court, no matter who prepared the draft or with what tool.
1. Each cited ruling is opened by its case number in the register of commercial cases, and the date and instance match.
2. The quote is checked against the text of the ruling, not against a summary in the AI’s answer.
3. Legal rules are checked against the version of the law in force on the date of the disputed relations.
4. The filing deadline is recalculated from the date in the court ruling, not from the date the letter arrived.
5. The lawyer who signs the document marks in the case card that the check is done.
AI can take the first pass: list all citations from the draft, find each one in the database of rulings and flag those that are not there. A cassation appeal can have many citations, and machine checking removes the routine, but not the responsibility.
The decision, the signature and the position at the hearing stay with the lawyer. You can start with a pilot on one process, for example preparing appeals and cassation appeals: this way the firm sees the hours saved on its own cases before it expands the system.